The community has a Boca Raton mailing address, but it has never been part of the city. When Boca came asking, one of the wealthiest neighborhoods in the country decided it was better off staying in the county.
Key Takeaways
- St. Andrews Country Club rejected Boca Raton's annexation pitch after its HOA concluded the city offered no significant added benefits.
- The community's $1.3 billion tax base would have moved from Palm Beach County's rolls to the city's.
- St. Andrews used the annexation talks as leverage, and the Sheriff's Office agreed to increase patrols and meet with community leadership biweekly.
Here is something that surprises a lot of buyers. St. Andrews Country Club has a "Boca Raton, FL 33496" mailing address, but it is not actually in the city of Boca Raton. It sits in unincorporated Palm Beach County, west of Jog Road and north of Clint Moore Road, outside the city limits. The postal service assigns addresses by delivery zone, not municipal boundary, so the city on your mail says which post office serves you, not which government you pay.
That distinction is the whole reason this story exists. According to the Boca Raton Tribune, the city of Boca Raton tried to annex St. Andrews, one of the wealthiest private communities in the country, and the community said no thanks. What happened in between is a lesson in leverage, and it matters for anyone buying or selling in these unincorporated pockets.
What did Boca Raton offer, and why did St. Andrews pass?
Former Mayor Scott Singer sent the community a letter outlining the city's pitch: roughly 2% in property tax savings, faster emergency response times, more police coverage, and government meetings in Boca Raton instead of West Palm Beach. In exchange, the community's $1.3 billion tax base (yes, for just one neighborhood) would have shifted from the county's rolls to the city's.
That trade is the heart of it. As Larry Mastropieri put it on the Discover South Florida Podcast: "One of the reasons they want to do that is because they get to collect the tax dollars and, well, why not annex the most expensive real estate in Palm Beach County or in the country?"
St. Andrews did not just say no, though. It shopped the offer. As Larry described it: "St. Andrews' HOA formed a committee that met with both city and county officials and said, you know, tell us, tell us what you're going to do for us." The committee concluded that the proposed annexation would not provide significant additional benefits and that the county is currently performing well.
Then came the payoff. In Larry's words: "The sheriff's office agreed to increase patrols and conduct biweekly meetings with the community's leadership." St. Andrews used the city's pitch to leverage better county service, then stayed put. A Boca Raton spokesperson confirmed that there is no longer an ongoing discussion of annexation to the city.
Why does a Boca Raton address not mean you live in Boca Raton?
Buyers ask this all the time. If your home sits in unincorporated Palm Beach County, you pay taxes to the county and get your services from the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office and county Fire Rescue, not the city. Dozens of communities across the county carry city-name addresses while sitting in unincorporated territory, so St. Andrews is the famous example, not the only one.
The differences show up in small ways too. Larry's favorite example is the beach pass: Boca Raton residents can buy an inexpensive annual pass to the city's beach parks, which are better than most people realize. County residents outside the city limits cannot get that pass. They have access to county parks like South Beach Park, but a day at a city park like Spanish River means paying the daily rate, around $35.
For real estate purposes, the bigger items are your tax rate, service providers, code enforcement, and eligibility for city programs. It all depends on whether you are inside the municipal boundary, not on what your mail says. Before you buy, verify the actual jurisdiction with the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser. It pairs with the other big cost question in these communities: how club dues affect home values.
Buying near Boca Raton and not sure if a home is inside the city limits or what that means for your taxes and services? Talk to a real estate agent in Boca Raton who has this conversation with relocating buyers every week. Reach out to The Mastropieri Group or call (561) 544-7000.
What is the annexation playbook in Palm Beach County?
St. Andrews is one chapter in a longer story. Palm Beach County Fire Rescue has warned that municipal annexation efforts are targeting affluent unincorporated communities, pulling high-value tax base out of the county while its fire stations stay put. County officials note that annexations routinely skip lower-value areas, with Boynton Beach bypassing several mobile-home parks while annexing higher-end developments.
Under Florida law, a city cannot force this. Annexation of an unincorporated area requires public hearings and a vote by its residents, which is why St. Andrews got to decide and why the leverage play worked. Boca Raton has grown this way for decades, gradually annexing property, and it has already directed staff to study annexing La Locque, another nearby unincorporated community, though no formal proposal has been made. The city has plenty of other growth debates running at the same time, as the One Boca referendum fight showed.
The takeaway for owners: if your property sits in an unincorporated pocket next to a growing city in Palm Beach County, your tax jurisdiction could change someday, and your vote decides it. It is worth knowing who provides your services now and how organized your community is. St. Andrews showed what an organized community can extract just by listening to the pitch. The broader tax conversation is not going away either, with Florida's property tax debate still very much alive.
What kind of community is St. Andrews Country Club?
For context on why the city wanted it so badly: St. Andrews has more than 700 custom-built homes on 720 acres, including 70 acres of lakes and two 18-hole golf courses. The buy-in fee is $500,000, one of the highest in the country, and Platinum Clubs of America has ranked it as high as 15th nationally. Homes there regularly sell for $5 million and above, and it is a fixture on any list of luxury country clubs in the Boca Raton area.
Security is part of the identity too. The community runs armed, roaming private security with response times measured in seconds, comparable to Royal Palm Yacht and Country Club in East Boca.
Watch More on This Topic: Watch this segment | Full Episode | Watch Last week's recap
Frequently Asked Questions
Is St. Andrews Country Club in the city of Boca Raton?
No. It carries a Boca Raton mailing address and ZIP code 33496, but it sits in unincorporated Palm Beach County. Residents pay county taxes and receive county services.
Why did St. Andrews reject the annexation?
Its HOA formed a committee, met with both city and county officials, and concluded that the annexation would not provide significant additional benefits, since the county was already performing well. The Sheriff's Office also agreed to increase patrols, which addressed the city's main selling point.
Can Boca Raton annex a community without its consent?
No. Under Florida law, annexing an unincorporated area requires public hearings and a vote by the residents of that area. A city cannot force annexation unilaterally, which is why the decision belonged to St. Andrews.
How do I know if a home is inside Boca Raton city limits?
Do not rely on the mailing address. Check the parcel with the Palm Beach County Property Appraiser to confirm the actual taxing jurisdiction. Your tax rate, services, code enforcement, and city program eligibility all depend on the real boundary.
How much does it cost to buy into St. Andrews Country Club?
The membership buy-in fee is $500,000, one of the highest in the country. The community has more than 700 custom homes on 720 acres, with two 18-hole golf courses, and homes regularly sell for $5 million or more.
Local help for buyers and investors in Boca Raton
If you are buying, selling, or investing in Boca Raton, Highland Beach, or the nearby unincorporated communities, it helps to work with a team that knows exactly where the city limits run and what that means for your costs. Reach out to The Mastropieri Group Realtors®. For practical, hands-on support across Boca Raton, call (561) 544-7000. You can also browse current homes for sale in Boca Raton.
Posted by Larry Mastropieri
Enjoy this blog post? Click here to subscribe for updates
Leave A Comment